| Year | First-Team All-Conference |
| 1993 | None |
| 1994 | None |
| 1997 | Becky Hart |
| Lori Michaud | |
| Brooke Dreske | |
| Sarah Bennett | |
| Heidi Wagner | |
| 1998 | Lori Michaud |
| Jenny Berg | |
| Brooke Dreske | |
| Sarah Bennett | |
| Becky Hart | |
| Carla Stephany | |
| 1999 | Brooke Dreske |
| Jenny Berg | |
| 2000 | Jenny Berg |
| 2001 | Jenny Berg |
| Mary Beth Meisinger | |
| Dana Fierce | |
| Pam Bassler | |
| Elaina Lee | |
| 2002 | Elaina Lee |
| 2003 | Kelly Campbell |
| Elaina Lee | |
| Carissa Foley | |
| 2004 | Alexandra Arasmith |
| Elizabeth Gibbs | |
| Cara Heckman | |
| Alison Korinek | |
| Mary Beth Meisinger | |
| Melissa Mennig | |
| 2005 | Alexandra Arasmith |
| Kelly Campbell | |
| Melissa Mennig | |
| Veronica Ragan | |
| Alison Korinek, honorable mention | |
| 2007 |
Melissa Guthrie |
| Alexandra Arasmith | |
| Katlyn Laughin | |
| Shannon Ford, honorable mention | |
| 2008 | Katlyn Laughlin |
| Ashley Kass, honorable mention | |
| Melissa Guthrie, honorable mention | |
| 2009 | Kelsey Gleich |
| Ashley Kass | |
| Bekah Willich | |
| Takara Harden, honorable mention |










